Order Catering for Your Next Event!
Milk Sugar Love Jersey City
19 McWilliams Place, Jersey City, NJ
Change location
Featured Items

Matcha Cookie
Matcha ice cream with our own handmade chocolate cream-filled cookies$12.00
The Midnight Cookie
Layers of Cookies 'n' Cream ice cream, Chocolate Cookie Crunch and Midnight Cookie ice cream with specialty sprinkles. Serves 8-10 people$45.00
Sugar Paste Message Plaque
A sugar paste plaque (it's completely edible!) inscribed with your CUSTOM MESSAGE in edible ink. Please leave your message in the Special Instructions box when adding this item to your cart! *MAX NUMBER OF CHARACTERS: 21*$5.00
Main Menu
Ice Cream Pints

Vanilla Bean
America's favorite flavor, made with real vanilla bean seeds and pure vanilla extract$12.00
Classic Chocolate
Chocolate ice cream made with the highest quality melted dark chocolate$14.00
Lemon Olive Oil
Creamy lemon olive oil ice cream made with lemon-infused Sicilian olive oil$12.00
Salted Caramel
Caramel ice cream made with just enough sea salt to enhance its rich flavor$12.00
Honey Lavender
Honey ice cream made with local honey and organic lavender extract$12.00
Earl Grey Fudge
Earl grey tea infused ice cream with a generous ripple of housemade fudge$12.00
Strawberry
A childhood favorite made with puréed strawberries---never any artificial colors or flavors$14.00
Midnight Cocoa
Jet black ice cream made with activated charcoal and cocoa powder$12.00
Alfajores 'n' Cream
Sweet Cream ice cream with our own Alfajores cookies---light buttery cookies filled with dulce de leche and rolled in coconut$12.00
Guava Cream Cheese
Cream Cheese ice cream with handmade Guava ripple$12.00OUT OF STOCK
Matcha Cookie
Matcha ice cream with our own handmade chocolate cream-filled cookies$12.00
**NEW** Chai Brownie
Chai ice cream (a black tea ice cream with cardamom, ginger, black pepper and cinnmaon) with handmade fudge brownie bites$14.00
**NEW** Carmen Rosa's Dominican Cake
Made in Collaboration with Carmen Rosa's Bakery in Jersey City. Vanessa and her mom have been making Dominican Cakes for decades now and it is the best I've ever tasted. Almond ice cream, Guava Jam Ripple, blue meringue crumble, pieces of buttery cake from Vanessa's kitchen$14.00
**NEW** Summer Strawberry
We roast then puree fresh New Jersey strawberries then blend them into our milk and cream to make this incredible, once-a-year flavor. Brighter and more buttery than our classic Strawberry ice cream, this is one not to miss!$15.00OUT OF STOCK
Ice Cream Sandwiches

Coffee Chip
Two housemade chocolate chip cookies filled with coffee ice cream and rolled in chocolate coffee cookie crumb$6.75
Birthday Sprinkle
Two housemade Confetti Sprinkle cookies filled with Vanilla Bean ice cream and rolled in Rainbow Sprinkles$6.75
Red Velvet Dream
Two housemade Red Velvet Dark Chocolate cookies filled with Cream Cheese ice cream$6.75
PB Brownie
Two layers of Fudge Brownie filled with Peanut Butter ice cream and candied peanuts, dipped in chocolate shell and sprinkled with sea salt$8.00OUT OF STOCK
Fruity Cereal Mac Daddy
Two fruity cereal French macarons filled with fruity cereal ice cream and rolled in Fruity Cereal$8.00OUT OF STOCK
Ice Cream Cakes

The Classic
Layers of Vanilla Bean ice cream, Chocolate Cookie Crunch, Classic Chocolate ice cream and Rainbow Sprinkles. Serves 8-10 people.$45.00OUT OF STOCK
The Midnight Cookie
Layers of Cookies 'n' Cream ice cream, Chocolate Cookie Crunch and Midnight Cookie ice cream with specialty sprinkles. Serves 8-10 people$45.00
The Fruity Cereal Mac Daddy
A giant sandwich cake made with two Fruity Cereal French macarons filled with Fruity Cereal ice cream and rolled in Fruity Cereal. Serves 8-10 people$45.00OUT OF STOCK
The Super Sammie
Two giant Sea Salt Chocolate Chip cookies filled with Vanilla Bean ice cream and rolled in Rainbow Sprinkles$45.00
Sugar Paste Message Plaque
A sugar paste plaque (it's completely edible!) inscribed with your CUSTOM MESSAGE in edible ink. Please leave your message in the Special Instructions box when adding this item to your cart! *MAX NUMBER OF CHARACTERS: 21*$5.00
Birthday Candles
One dozen pre-packed rainbow candles$5.00
Bakeshop Treats

Fudge Brownie
Made with Cocoa Powder and melted chocolate and just enough flour to hold it all together$5.25
Raspberry Crumb Bar
Brown sugar shortbread crust with layers of raspberry jam and brown sugar crumb topping$4.50
Magic Bar
A salted graham crust covered with layers of chocolate, coconut, dulce de leche, toffee and toasted almonds$4.50
Sea Salt Chocolate Chip Cookie
Our buttery best seller made with milk and dark chocolates and a sprinkling of sea salt$1.95
One Dozen Sea Salt Chocolate Chip Cookies
Twelve of our buttery best sellers made with milk and dark chocolates and a sprinkling of sea salt$19.50
Red Velvet Dark Chocolate Cookie
A chewy Red Velvet cookie with dark chocoalte chips$1.95OUT OF STOCK
Confetti Sprinkle Cookie
An all butter sugar cookie with a sprinkling of classic rainbow sprinkles$1.95OUT OF STOCK
Catering
Bakeshop Treats
Sea Salt Chocolate Chip Cookies
Our cookies are baked fresh for your order and made with all butter and dark and milk chocolates. Cookies come packaged in a white bakery box.$19.50Fudge Brownies
Our delicious fudge brownies made with Cocoa Powder and melted chocolate and just enough flour to hold it all together.Packaged in a white bakery box.$24.50
Ice Cream
Ice Cream Sandwiches
Sandwiches are individually packaged with ingredient and allergen information. If you are traveling further than 15 minutes away, please add the foam cooler and dry ice option to your order. Our ice cream is all natural, without any chemical stabilizers and will begin to melt immediately without the protection of dry ice and an insulated cooler. 4 Birthday Sprinkle, 4 Coffee Chip, 4 Red Velvet Dream (flavor mix cannot be changed)$72.00Single Serve Ice Cream Cups
Individual 5 oz cups with lids, labels and allergen information.$96.00Foam Cooler with Dry Ice
An insulated foam cooler (19 1/2" x 12 1/2" x 12 1/2" - 1 1/2" Thick) perfect for transporting ice cream sandwich orders or single serve ice cream cups. Includes enough dry ice to store product inside for up to 24 hours. Can fit up to 48 single serve cups and up to 48 ice cream sandwiches.$100.00

Matcha Cookie
$12.00
Matcha ice cream with our own handmade chocolate cream-filled cookies
1